Why creative is more important than ever in advertising.

In: Fascinating

15 May 2009

This week I gave a speech at the Facebook Global Sales Conference, up in Palo Alto, on the role of creativity in social media. I enjoyed meeting and hanging out with the Facebook team. A lot of energy and excitement going on there.

The theme for my presentation, on Google Docs here, is that social media is going to usher in a big demand for creativity in advertising.

The Power of Social Media

Recently there’s been some highly-illuminating information on the impact of social media. Firstly, we’re seeing social media driving a lot of traffic to sites. The average for this is 20% of a site’s visitors. That means for some sites, it’s significantly higher.

This is one of Google’s challenges. As a search tool, it’s far from perfect. And people are finding that their network is a more effective resource than Google, in many ways. Twitter’s ability to provide relevant search info quickly paints a similar story.

And when you think about it, of course your friends are going to be better at predicting what you’d like than a Google algorithm. That’s why they’re your friends. Friendships are based on shared interests.

But perhaps the ultimate proof of social media’s power is the almighty conversion. And here we’re seeing conversion numbers 2-4 times higher. That’s a remarkable leap in performance — a stat even a direct marketer can love.

Paid Media Isn’t Going Away

While social media is undeniably powerful, keep in mind that no matter how popular it gets this year, the overwhelming portion of ad spending will be paid media. And frankly, paid media will  be a big factor for a long time.

Paid media actually makes for a great partnership with social media. There are only a handful of sites that have risen to prominence without any paid media. And a lot of the so-called viral or social media success stories were heavily fueled by a paid media launch. That’s all fine. In fact, it’s the way it should be. Companies rarely have time for 100% organic viral growth. Sometimes you have to spike the punch.

The question then is, What’s the tactical relationship between paid and social media?

Turning Paid Impressions into Social Endorsements

So paid media can feed the social media monster. The question is, How?

Any social media campaign has one major requirement. That it be something people want to share. Without that, it’s not social. Just more stuff posted to the Web.

Having something share-worthy isn’t easy, as few products are what Seth Godin would call “purple cows” — products that generate their own word of mouth. Outside of entertainment properties, it’s hard to think of a category in which people watch the ads as a way of gaining product information.

So the ‘news factor’ has to come from somewhere.

A base level tactic is to include sharing features at every touchpoint of your campaign. Make it easier for people to take it social. This could be Facebook Connect and other types of universal logins on all your campaign assets — from websites to banners. But those are really more foundational tactics. And it also assumes that the ad or website we’re featuring has inherent news-worthiness. Not a likely situation.

Creatively-speaking, social media is a much more challenging environment. In my presentation to Facebook, I mentioned that there are a lot of paid media ads that most people would consider pretty bad from a messaging standpoint (think the Clapper, or the Snuggie), yet they’re still able to produce positive numbers. They’ll drive a certain level of traffic, some of which will convert to sales.

With paid media, the biggest requirement from the reader is to simply NOT skip or ignore the ad. Think about that. To ‘not’ receive a paid media placement, you have to do something. That’s ironic. With social media, there has to be some sort of action on some person’s behalf, to generate the endorsement.

That makes understanding the consumer more important than ever. Because you have to gauge what will interest them at a much deeper level. When you hit it, it’s extremely powerful, as the conversion rates are showing. But it’s not a level of creative thinking that you can simply phone in.

So the ‘creative’, whatever that may be, has to be something that will separate from the rest of the media noise. And that’s probably not an ad, unless it’s insanely funny.

Content-based creative, like video and Facebook apps, offer a lot of potential impact. But they’re going to have to respond to what will inevitably be a surge in similar campaigns. All vying for people’s endorsement.

So getting any sizeable reaction from viewers is going to require a big leap in creative over what everyone else is putting out there. After all, consumers aren’t going to increase their rates of endorsing. In fact, it’s going to decrease on a percentage basis as more and more companies swing for a social media hit.

In that environment, the creative will definitely be king. Outside of product development itself, it will be the only thing that can get a company into the conversation. But it’s going to take a lot of understanding, thinking, learning, and refining.

In short, it’s going to take a lot of creativity.

6 Responses to Why creative is more important than ever in advertising.

Avatar

Eric Tsai

May 19th, 2009 at 8:45 am

Great post on creativity. I totally agree that online ads are getting to a point where users can easily ignore, and even if they’re those dancing ladies with mortgage rates next to them (:

I would also add that the shift in perceived value will have a dramatic influence on the future of creativity. There is a good and a bad side in a time like this, you have more people trying to be creative to keep their jobs and keep their clients, and you have those out of jobs trying to reinvent. And with the convergence of technology, creative people are relying more on tools rather than imagination.

Similar to innovation, many creative people are restricted to knowledge and just like what Albert Einstein said “imagination is more important than knowledge, knowledge is limited.”

Avatar

Doug Schumacher

May 19th, 2009 at 9:12 am

Eric,

Thanks for the added insights. You tapped into the reliance of tools, which is interesting because one thing I heard from the Facebook people is that a lot of agency creatives are looking for technological solutions for creative problems. There’s a sense that the technology always has to have a new angle to it for creatives to be able to come up with something distinct. And of course, that’s not much more feasible than for TV to ‘reinvent’ the technology for each campaign.

Also, per your comment on out of work creatives, at SXSW I saw Tim Hwang of ROFLcon make a compelling case for how social media was exploding with so many out of work people, or at least people who weren’t as busy as they were last year. And I think it’s playing out.

Avatar

David Catalano

May 22nd, 2009 at 1:30 pm

I agree on the need for endorsement as a precursor to sharing (sneezing). I was thrilled when Facebook introduced Social Ads. Have you ever seen stats on the performance of social ads vs. non-social ones on Facebook?

Thanks for blogging!

Avatar

Doug Schumacher

May 22nd, 2009 at 1:44 pm

David,

Thanks for the note. I haven’t done an exact comparison between the engagement and standard units, but are planning it on an upcoming campaign (we do a lot of testing). There’s been no shortage of options stating display ads on social nets don’t work, but from first and second hand experience, I’ve seen both the MSN flash and the Facebook units perform well. As with most ads, it probably comes down to strategy and message, right?

This is pretty rich territory, so I’m sure this won’t be my last post on it.

Thanks for reading.

Avatar

Tom Richards

May 28th, 2009 at 10:18 pm

Hi Doug,
Well written. I totally agree. Thanks for sharing this.

A bit off topic but this got me thinking about a story I heard on NPR this afternoon. Claude Brodesser Acker (sp?) was talking about “Anvil, the Story of Anvil.” Reportedly VH1 has the video rights so really wants it to do well in the theater. However the film doesn’t have major studio support. So, VH1 has sent copies to artists it is very close to who have huge followings on twitter,etc (John Mayer was mentioned as well as a few others.) All based on the idea that they will view and support the film to their followers, those followers retweet, so on and so on.

Where the creative unit is not being passed, but instead inspires those with followings to create a bit of echo viral. Much less hamfisted than the half-a-dozen clients that have asked for a “viral something” over the past few years, when they mean make my product ad and get people to watch it for free.

One point they made is that this would never work for Gilette or Ford or whatever else that is unlkely to tell a story that is not totally self serving. Really, any brand that is not willing to put it on the line and really be creative.

Influencing the influencers is not new of course, just a new medium to spread the word. The really interesting part was the speculation that there wouldn’t be much support besides this, giving as close to a controlled environment for a twitter only campaign for a marketable product so far (that I can think of at least.)

Yeah, there’s all the PR around the film that will skew the results, but nothing is perfect I suppose.

An interesting experiment none-the-less. And a film I want to see, even if it is total BS.

thanks for indulging.

Avatar

Doug Schumacher

May 31st, 2009 at 10:23 am

Tom,

You’re dead on. The ‘Anvil’ case you mention is a perfect example of how entertainment properties have a natural advantage in social media marketing. Especially when they can get key celebs involved, per the ‘Anvil’ situation.

Brands will definitely have to work harder than a movie to get people to pass it along.

If you come across any stats regarding how the Anvil campaign goes, I’d love to hear. I’ll be looking for it as well.

Thanks for posting.

Comment Form

Hi

Welcome. I'm a digital media strategist, creative director and entrepreneur. I like to explore various digital media platforms, and this is one of my blog outlets. I also write "Creativing", a weekly update on the latest developments in content marketing and online creativity, posted every Thursday at Creativing and iMedia. If you'd like a more ongoing stream of my thoughts, work or otherwise, feel free to connect with me on Facebook. My profile widget is below. Thanks.

ds_portrait_dscom
View Doug Schumacher's profile on LinkedIn

RSS Creativing RSS Feed